Go to main nav Go to content Go to footer

Clauses Deemed Unwritten in Divided Co-ownership

The Legal Limits of the Declaration of Co-ownership

News

By Camille Joli-Coeur, co-ownership lawyer at Dunton Rainville

Every declaration of co-ownership constitutes the fundamental contractual framework of a divided co-ownership. However, the scope of this notarized document is not unlimited.

The legislature has provided for situations in which a clause in a declaration of co-ownership is deemed unwritten, either explicitly or by inference. In practice, such clauses are sometimes still applied until their invalidity is raised by a co-owner or anyone with an interest in taking legal action. Such situations can understandably be a source of uncertainty within a co-ownership.

A contractual clause is deemed unwritten when it does not comply with a mandatory provision of the law. Article 1438 C.C.Q. provides that a null clause does not invalidate the contract unless the contract must be considered an indivisible whole. The article further specifies that the same applies to a clause that is without effect or deemed unwritten.

There are three categories of clauses that may be deemed unwritten in divided co-ownership.

1. Clauses Infringing upon the Powers of Decision-making Bodies

Clauses Modifying the Required Voting Majorities

The declaration of co-ownership must comply with the mandatory governance rules established by the Civil Code of Québec and cannot modify the decision-making mechanisms it provides. Certain clauses that seek to circumvent the majorities prescribed by law or alter the conditions for adopting decisions may therefore be declared inoperative. Indeed, article 1101 C.C.Q. expressly provides that any stipulation in the declaration of co-ownership which changes the number of votes required to take a decision provided for in the chapter on divided co-ownership, namely articles 1038 to 1109 C.C.Q., is deemed unwritten.

Clauses Allowing the Board of Directors to Amend the By-laws of the Immovable

Under article 1096 C.C.Q., the legislature grants exclusive authority to the meeting of co-owners, rather than the board of directors, to amend the by-laws of the immovable. Consequently, clauses in a declaration of co-ownership that would allow the board of directors, for example, to modify rules governing the use of private portions or the enjoyment of common portions, or the procedures for assessing and collecting common expenses, must be deemed unwritten. The same applies to the composition of the board of directors and the appointment and replacement of directors. All these matters fall within the scope of the by-laws of the immovable and may therefore only be amended by the meeting of co-owners. Although article 1096 C.C.Q. does not expressly address the concept of a clause deemed unwritten, the combined effect of articles 1060 and 1096 C.C.Q. leads us to this conclusion.

However, it is not always easy to distinguish between management directives or rules that the board of directors may adopt in the exercise of its management powers and amendments to the by-laws of the immovable. Nevertheless, this distinction remains essential, since the by-laws of the immovable may only be amended by a decision of the meeting of co-owners.

Clauses Authorizing Certain Work on Common Portions in Advance

A clause in the declaration of co-ownership granting the developer the right to unilaterally carry out work to alter, enlarge or improve common portions should be considered contrary to article 1097 C.C.Q. Such work on common portions requires a decision made by co-owners representing three quarters of the votes of the co-owners present or represented at the meeting of co-owners. A clause in the declaration of co-ownership allowing the developer to take the place of the meeting of co-owners for such work would circumvent the mandatory governance rules established by the legislature. It would therefore be deemed unwritten.

It should be noted, however, that the distinction between the completion of work falling within the developer’s obligations and work subject to article 1097 C.C.Q. may sometimes be difficult to establish. The analysis must then focus on the actual nature of the proposed work and its impact on the immovable and the community of co-owners.

Clauses Allowing a Co-owner to Take the Place of the Meeting of Co-owners or the Board of Directors

A clause granting a co-owner decision-making authority that belongs to the meeting of co-owners or the board of directors could be challenged, as it would undermine the distribution of powers within the co-ownership. This would be the case, for example, with a provision allowing a co-owner to independently authorize major work, incur significant expenses or make a decision that would normally require a collective vote.

However, these situations must be distinguished from clauses intended simply to protect certain rights or allow legal recourse when the Syndicate of Co-owners remains inactive. Such a stipulation does not necessarily amount to taking the place of the co-ownership’s decision-making bodies; it all depends on its actual scope and effects.

Ultimately, the more a clause seeks to transfer to an individual co-owner the powers vested in the meeting of co-owners or the board of directors, the more likely it is to be considered incompatible with the principles of collective governance that characterize divided co-ownership.

2. Clauses Infringing upon the Voting Rights of Co-owners

Voting rights and the majorities required to make decisions are fundamental elements of the divided co-ownership regime. This is why the legislature has provided that clauses in a declaration of co-ownership that depart from these rules are deemed unwritten.

Clauses Modifying the Majorities Prescribed by Law

As previously mentioned, article 1101 C.C.Q. is categorical: “Any stipulation of the declaration of co-ownership which changes the number of votes required to take any decision contemplated in this chapter is deemed unwritten.”

Clauses requiring unanimity when the law provides for a qualified majority are therefore without effect, as are clauses lowering the majorities prescribed by law or establishing incompatible voting rules for certain decisions. This principle was notably applied in Pépin c. Syndicat de la copropriété Cop-Moncton (945-947-949 Moncton), 2006 QCCS 3179. In this case, the declaration of co-ownership, which predated the coming into force of the Civil Code of Québec, required unanimity among co-owners for decisions adopted by the meeting of co-owners. The court concluded that this stipulation could not be applied because it modified the number of votes required under articles 1096 to 1098 C.C.Q. Consequently, the clause was deemed unwritten pursuant to article 1101 C.C.Q., subject to the exception provided for in section 53 of the Act respecting the implementation of the reform of the Civil Code concerning decisions aimed at changing the destination of the immovable. In such cases, the unanimity requirement is maintained.

Clauses Altering the Principle of Proportional Representation

Article 1090 C.C.Q. establishes a fundamental principle of divided co-ownership, whereby each co-owner has a number of votes at the meeting of co-owners proportional to the relative value of their fraction. This rule ensures consistency between each co-owner’s decision-making power and their financial contribution to the common expenses of the immovable.

The mandatory nature of this provision was reaffirmed by the Court of Appeal in Syndicat de copropriétés Club Tremblant, bloc F-G c. Hôtel du lac Tremblant inc., 2013 QCCA 2004, which emphasized that article 1090 C.C.Q. establishes a fundamental distribution of rights and obligations within the co-ownership. The Court reiterated that a co-owner who holds a significant share of the relative value of the immovable benefits from a corresponding number of votes but must also assume a proportional contribution to common expenses. According to the Court, this distribution is an essential component of the balance intended by the legislature and cannot be modified by agreement.

In the same decision, the Court of Appeal also reiterated that the rules governing the exercise of voting rights are set out in articles 1090 and following C.C.Q., and that no provision in a declaration of co-ownership may modify the number of votes allocated to a co-owner based on considerations unrelated to the relative value of their fraction. Any clause in a declaration of co-ownership having such an effect may be declared null or deemed unwritten.

Similarly, a clause in a declaration of co-ownership that contravenes the mandatory rule set out in article 1064 C.C.Q., according to which co-owners’ contributions to common expenses must be proportional to the relative value of their respective fractions, would also be null, void and deemed unwritten.

Clauses Granting an Exclusive Right to Appoint a Director

When directors must be elected by the meeting of co-owners, a clause in the declaration of co-ownership granting a particular co-owner the exclusive authority to appoint or elect a director raises significant legal issues. In this regard, notary emerita and author Christine Gagnon emphasizes that provisions in a declaration of co-ownership that remove decisions normally falling within the authority of the meeting of co-owners must be examined with caution. An important distinction must nevertheless be made. In certain specific situations, particularly in phased co-ownerships, mixed-use co-ownerships or very small co-ownerships, the structure of the immovable may justify the declaration of co-ownership granting a co-owner or a category of co-owners the right to appoint one or more directors. Such stipulations must nevertheless comply with the mandatory provisions of the law and must not deprive other co-owners of the voting rights conferred upon them by articles 1090 and following C.C.Q.

3. Clauses Increasing the Civil Liability of Co-owners

The rules governing the liability of co-owners are mandatory and cannot be set aside, modified or made more onerous by the declaration of co-ownership. In the interests of fairness and the protection of all parties involved in the co-ownership, the legislature has expressly limited the circumstances in which a co-owner may be held liable towards the Syndicate of Co-owners. This legislative intervention is intended, in particular, to prevent contractual clauses from imposing automatic or excessive liability on a co-owner without regard for the fundamental principles of civil liability.

A Provision of Public Order

The first paragraph of article 1074.2 C.C.Q. establishes the circumstances in which a Syndicate of Co-owners may claim damages from a co-owner responsible for a loss. The second paragraph of this article adds an important qualification: “Any stipulation which is inconsistent with the provisions of the first paragraph is deemed unwritten.”

Article 1074.2 C.C.Q. is mandatory in nature. In Syndicat de la copropriété 650 Marcel-Laurin c. Neng, 2024 QCCQ 2022, the Court of Québec reiterated that the legislature had made this issue a matter of public order and that a declaration of co-ownership cannot increase a co-owner’s liability beyond the limits established by this article of the Code.

Clauses Unduly Transferring Certain Risks to Co-owners

A declaration of co-ownership cannot establish a more stringent liability regime than that provided for by the legislature. This issue has become particularly important since the 2018 reform of co-ownership insurance. Recent case law, notably Syndicat de la copropriété 650 Marcel-Laurin c. Neng, cited above, and Syndicat des copropriétaires du 1200 Ouest c. Sarhan, 2025 QCCS 434, demonstrates the courts’ willingness to enforce the limits imposed by article 1074.2 C.C.Q., by preventing declarations of co-ownership from being used to circumvent the applicable legislative framework.

The Absence of Automatic Liability for Co-owners

The prohibition against increasing the liability of co-owners does not, however, mean that they are immune from legal recourse. Article 1074.2 C.C.Q. expressly preserves the Syndicate of Co-owners’ right to obtain damages when a co-owner is bound to make reparation for injury caused by a proven fault on their part or, in circumstances provided for by the Civil Code, by the act of things in their custody (article 1465 C.C.Q.).

A Balance Between Individual and Collective Rights

This case law demonstrates that the legislature has sought to strike a balance between protecting the community of co-owners and protecting individual rights. On the one hand, the Syndicate of Co-owners retains the ability to take legal action when a co-owner’s liability is established. On the other hand, it cannot rely on a clause in the declaration of co-ownership to impose greater liability than that provided for by law.

Other Clauses Deemed Unwritten

Several other articles of the Civil Code expressly provide that a contractual clause must be deemed unwritten. One example is article 2402 C.C.Q., which may apply to divided co-ownership:

“In non-marine insurance, a general clause releasing the insurer in the event of violation of the law is deemed unwritten unless the violation is an indictable offence. A clause of the policy by which the insured, in the event of a loss, consents to an assignment of claim in favour of the insurer which would have the effect of granting the insurer more rights than it has under the rules of subrogation is also deemed unwritten.”

It should also be noted that, in divided co-ownership, article 1075.1 C.C.Q. limits the insurer’s subrogation rights.